Crayola Colored Pencils Review: The Classroom Standard, Tested

Colored pencils seem simple until you've dealt with weak color payoff or leads that snap under a kid's grip. Crayola's set has stayed a go-to for classrooms because it avoids both problems consistently.

Who it's for

A solid default for classrooms, homeschool supply lists, coloring-book hobbyists, and gifting to kids — anywhere reliability and a wide color range matter more than professional-grade blending. If you're shopping for a serious adult colorist or illustrator who wants heavy layering and blending capability, a dedicated art-line set (Crayola's own Signature line or artist-grade brands) will outperform this general-purpose set.

What we liked

• Strong, even color payoff on the first pass, without needing to press hard to get saturated color.
• Break-resistant leads hold up well to a young kid's grip and pressure, an actual pain point with cheaper sets.
• Pre-sharpened out of the box, ready to use immediately for classrooms or gifting.

What could be better

• Wood casing means they'll eventually need a sharpener, unlike mechanical colored pencils.
• 36 colors is generous but doesn't include as many skin-tone or blending shades as Crayola's higher-end art lines.

Key specs, explained

• 36-count: covers primary, secondary, and a good range of tertiary colors for general coloring and school projects; it's a step up from starter 12- or 24-count sets without jumping to a 50+ count art set most households don't need.
• Pre-sharpened: worth confirming a sharpener is on hand anyway — the factory point doesn't last past the first use for most kids, and a dedicated pencil sharpener rated for colored (not just graphite) pencils reduces breakage when resharpening softer colored-pencil leads.
• Age 3+ rating: reflects choking-hazard testing on the pencils themselves, not a claim about fine-motor skill level — younger kids will still need a jumbo or triangular-grip pencil for comfortable use.

Frequently asked questions

Q: Are these good for blending and shading, or just flat coloring? They handle basic layering and shading reasonably well for a general-use set, but they won't blend as smoothly as wax-based artist pencils — adequate for school projects and coloring books, limited for detailed illustration work.

Q: Do the colors match Crayola's crayon lineup? Largely yes — Crayola keeps its core color names consistent across product lines, though colored pencils and crayons use different pigment formulations, so shades can look slightly different side by side.

Q: Are they non-toxic and safe for young kids? Yes — Crayola colored pencils carry the AP (Approved Product) non-toxic seal, the standard safety certification for children's art materials in the US.

Should you buy it?

For classroom use, coloring books, or a reliable gift for kids, this is the easy default — it delivers on color quality and durability without paying art-supply prices.

Check price on Amazon